[Wiflewood]

I think that you people will find that this is the best Firefox/IE picture:

http://img281.echo.cx/img281/6339/firefox8ud.gif

Nice Set black mage. I like the Avatar, but not the sig too much. Could be more interesting. 7/10

Do you guys think that I should keep my set as it is, or use this new set I made?

http://img269.echo.cx/img269/9082/lesserdemonavatar2du.png
http://img266.echo.cx/img266/4959/lesserdemonsig3cj.png

[Elliott]

I prefer the current, the new one is a little plain, more colour or a nice render background would improve it.

[Izar]

Wiflewood, on May 28 2005, 01:52 AM, said:

I think that you people will find that this is the best Firefox/IE picture:

http://img281.echo.cx/img281/6339/firefox8ud.gif

Nice Set black mage. I like the Avatar, but not the sig too much. Could be more interesting. 7/10

Do you guys think that I should keep my set as it is, or use this new set I made?

http://img269.echo.cx/img269/9082/lesserdemonavatar2du.png
http://img266.echo.cx/img266/4959/lesserdemonsig3cj.png

Actually, I used the one I made for the IE/Mozilla because it's the actualy Icons together.

The new set is very plain, maybe ading something arounf the name would be better.

[Elliott]

At least your set matches now Izar, I'd just lose the stuff under the image, and make the image link to your site. Then you will avoid clutter and have a better looking signature.

[Izar]

Which one? Oh, I don't know why my avatar didn't match at irst, it showed the Dragon still in FireFox, but in IE it showed it perfectly fine.

The image isn't a link cuz it's Norma Jean, and Norma jean deserves it's own little space, or big space. :lol: Plus, most people arn't interested in my site. Thanks.

Even though Golden Djinni hasn't psot here, i lvoe his signature, cuz Family guy rocks! 9/10 cuz it's way too big.

[Elliott]

Firefox must have kept it in the cache or something like that, happens a lot.

[Izar]

Yeah, that's what I was thinking. It's fine now, I think...

Agatio: 4/10 WAY too plain for a signature image. And I don't see why you put the Cross of Andrew(or peter) on it, your not religious. Oh wells. The avatar doesn't match the sig, but that doesn't matter, it's small, and an eye... 7/10.

[Elliott]

If you didn't notice it's an inverted cross =/

[Blink]

Not really a set, it's plain on one side, and detailed on the other. Really doesn't go well together, but since it says Agatio above your icon and in your sig, that matches, 2/10 set.

Avatar is very nice, but it looks like there's something more we aren't seeing of that image. If you would post the rest of it as a sig, it would help. 8/10

Sig, hm. It's kinda bland, but the text sorta matches the crosses. And, inverted crosses, what's with that? Is that satanic or something? I've heard of burning crosses, but I dunno about inverted. Still, nice, but bland, and even blander with that avatar. 6/10

Also, it would be the cross of peter, who said he wasn't worthy to die the same way as Jesus, so he was crucified upside down, but actually, it wasn't on an inverted cross. Rather, it was more of an X cross, which he was put on upside down. Really as different from a crucifiction but still considered a crucifiction as possible.

[Elliott]

It was quick I'll admit, and the eye is part of an album cover.

[Andross]

New set. Mas abstracto! Mas colores! WEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!

[Neo]

Andross: awesome dude, just awesome. 9.9/10 the 0.1 misses because of the text.

[Andross]

Hold it! I committed blasphemy now. MUWAHAHAHAHA! :P

Try 468x60/500x100, stick the logo on the left, then put the text in. And of course, a border. Nice logo btw, did you make it?

Avatar: I currently have a fetish with multi colored things, so it's plain to me at the moment.

Overall: 7.5/10

[Elliott]

Love the set Andross, like your new piece on dA. The AD banner has always been good, and the text is ok. 9/10 for set.

[Excalibur's Power]

Andross--Tha's really cool, I like the effects, but the text isnt just that good...[no it isnt because it says "God" :P]

Rating--9/10

The text makes it lose one point.

[Neo]

EP: strange, but it hurts my eyes. dont like the border, and the bg is really... simple, looks a bit like an image you grabbed off the internet, the render is ok, but not great. text isn't that good too. 5.5/10

[Elliott]

Nice matching set EP. A little monochrome, but looks nice overall. 7/10 for set.

[Neo]

Agatio-- that dude is psycho... looks like a freaked out pyscho killer... 8/10 like it =)

[Echo_djinn]

Agatio: I always wondered how it would look like if you cried blood. Now I know. 7/10. A dead man's cry.

[Elliott]

In case anyone is interested, it's Galder, the singer and guitarist for Old Man's Child, and the guitarist for Dimmu Borgir, musical genius.

ED has the old set back it looks like, sig image is plain, but not ugly, and the sonic avatar doesn't match. 5/10 for set.

[Mathak Kraven]

I rate your new av a 7/10 Agatio, but I already rated your siggy.

[Elliott]

Humerous signature Mathak, links could look a little better (make them black and lose the '!'s. Avatar is great, I'll save that to my comp, haven't seen an FF avatar yet.

6/10 for set, could be better.

[Mathak Kraven]

I will lose the exclamation marks but the color coding is for a reason.

[Wiflewood]

Gatty: cool avvie, you can really feel his expression. Size is a bit off. Maybe make it square + add border?

8/10

[Mathak Kraven]

The avatar actually is the FireFox logo. I didn't make it. Nor did I make the dancing MC Hammer.

I like the monstruous avatar and sig Wifle. 9.2/10

[Izar]

Agatio, on May 31 2005, 05:04 PM, said:

If you didn't notice it's an inverted cross =/

The upside down/inverted cross is actually the symbol used for Andrew's Cross, since he didn't want to be crucified the same way as Jesus, because he deemed himself, "unworthy."

ANdross: Nice one there, 8/10 because some of the light looks like it's not sopposed to be there.

[Elliott]

@Wifle: Nah, I got tired of 100x100 avatars, thought I'd try something new.

You sig is good, but the character could be blended a LOT better, and maybe make the text easier to read. 6/10 for set.

[l3lueMage]

Agatio Text sig, sorry I suck at rating those...

Izar yours is plane, yet pretty cool ^^ 7/10 lol I dunno ><

[Yuki]

omiegosh I love it l3luemage! It's classy and the text is nice, plus it's also so very sweet. Nice job!!!!!! 9.9/10

I don't even wanna know what my sig rating would be *cough* -600/10 *cough*

[Elliott]

Izar, on Jun 5 2005, 07:51 AM, said:

The upside down/inverted cross is actually the symbol used for Andrew's Cross, since he didn't want to be crucified the same way as Jesus, because he deemed himself, "unworthy."

ANdross: Nice one there, 8/10 because some of the light looks like it's not sopposed to be there.

I was using it because of a different theory:
http://www.jesus-is-lord.com/anti5.htm

[l3lueMage]

strange sig agatio, is it supposed to be the devil o.o
8/10 the black eyes are creepy

[Elliott]

Cropped album art (In Defiance Of Existence - Old Man's Child). I just think that's one of the best album covers of all time :) . See the original here: http://www.lordofevil666.blogger.com.br/In...20Existence.jpg . And yes, I'm sure it has some kind of satanical theme to it.

Ok Bluemage, your avatar looks very tacky (Maple Story character?) edges look rough, colouring isn't that great, overall, not a very good avatar. I think your signature would be more suited to an anime fan girl to be honest. Use of strong colours, a cliche quite, and of course, anime characters, kissing? Not a great set, doesn't match, doesn't suit you, and the images themselves aren't too great. I KNOW you can do better. 2/10 for set.

[Luna]

Agatio: 10/10 for everything D:
The effects you added to the eye really add an...elegant touch to it. As for the sig, purple is one of my favourite colours and, I agree, that cover art is really great o.o

[l3lueMage]

Sheba urs has some dark humor x-x 9/10

Changed mine =]

[Elliott]

..to something more suiting. It's definately better Bluemage, suits you more, text looks better, image looks better. All you need now is a good avatar. 6.7/10 for set.

[l3lueMage]

There hehe, well since I have nothing else to rate I shall rate YOUR EYE...
its a dirty eye, I think it should take a shower XDDD 11/10...why 11 because it scared me and I accidentally pressed 1 twice -__-

[Mathak Kraven]

I like your sig Blue mage, it get's a 9.5/10

[Izar]

l3lueMage, on Jun 5 2005, 04:30 AM, said:

Agatio Text sig, sorry I suck at rating those...

Izar yours is plane, yet pretty cool ^^ 7/10 lol I dunno ><

And all mine... is a cd cover. lol, with just NORMA JEAN added to it. :)

I think I rated your Eye, Agatio, maybe it was another. 7/10 Plain, but it's an eye and eyes rock.

[Someone Else]

ZOMG check it out. I like this set alot. =)

I think I rated Izar...

Well it's cool, I suppose. That songs sorta cool, but I heard better.

The whole thing: 7/10

[Luna]

WD's set is amusing n.n
9/10 For amusing Shebah.

[Someone Else]

Thanks Sheba. :)

Anyways, it's emo right? I give it... a 9/10 cause it isn't a 10 to me. XD

[Elliott]

Love the maple set WD. Maybe a bigger avatar would be nice, and better dimensions for the signature, but from a fellow Maple Story fan, it's pretty cool :) . 7/10 for set.

[Neo]

I know I dont have a sig -- yet, but what do you people think of my avatar? (the I stands for my nick -- Iced).

[Someone Else]

Agatio, on Jun 7 2005, 07:03 AM, said:

Love the maple set WD. Maybe a bigger avatar would be nice, and better dimensions for the signature, but from a fellow Maple Story fan, it's pretty cool ^_^ . 7/10 for set.

Yeah, I'm not quite sure what happened to the pixels for my avatar... *newbie to APS :) * Still ended up looking nice though. :D

Neo Gen: It's a great avatar, really. =) Could use a little bit of Sharpening from APS maybe, but it really is nice to look at. 8/10

[Izar]

Wind Dude - Nice, 7/10 - it's good, just... I dunno, seems like just an image, not meant to be a banner, dunno.

Neo - Iced. lol, good, but it could, as WD said, use a bit of sharpening. 7/10

[Neo]

New sate, plz give it a rating

[Elliott]

RATE SOMEONE ELSE'S.
I've lost count of how many times I've told people that.

Sig's good, I lurve the effects on the guys, and the fonts/text suit it well. Avatar should match, so it lets down the set. 7/10 overall (10 for the siggy :) )

[Izar]

The avatar does match. I'd give it a 7/10, mainly because it's just an arm... Good effects though.

[Elliott]

Aight, I must have still been seeing his old avatar (cashe related most likely).
Well since it matches now, I'd give you a 10 for that set. Great colours, character looks great, simple clean borders are always good :) .

[Nick Presta]

Agatio, your Sig and Avatar both get an 8/10 for being clean and simple.
Your set gets a 7/10 as a matching colour scheme would work better.

[Elliott]

Sorry Nick, I've never really been a fan of any of your sets. Current one doesn't match (I know mine doesn't either), the text on the avatar looks real bad, and it's background seems cheap and low quality. Sig is a little better maybe get an avatar that matches that? 4/10 overall.

[Neo]

Izar, an arm? hehe, yes true -- he has a large arm, but in the avatar you can also see his head.

Agatio -- very nice sig, you put a great color balance (if im correct) over it. the only thing that bothers me is the large white stroke. maybe just an Agatio, without the stroke would be better. 8.5/10 for the sig, because I still really like to look at it.
avatar is really good, dispite that they mot match, I still give your sen a 9/10, because the avatar is excellent.

[gsninja]

Neo Genesis-I'm not really sure who/what that is, but it looks pretty nice. I give a 9/10 for both the avie and the siggy. The set, 10/10, since they go perfectly together.

[Elliott]

@Neo_Genesis, colour balance is the tool of kings, use it correctly and you can make some wicked colours ^_^ .

Bad set GSN. Avatar is distorted due to wrong dimensions, and the sig, well, it speeks for itself. Unsmoothed fonts on a solid blue which creats bad contrast, 3 very separate images tacked on,. Very unbalanced and messy signature image. The banana gets you an extra point though because it just owns.

4/10 for set (would have been a 3 without that dancing banana, it is peanut butter jelly time).

[Mathak Kraven]

gsninja, I don't completely like your signature. I'm not a Kingdom Hearts Fan. I give yours a 6/10 avatar, a little more 6.5/10

I have a new av I believe.

[Black Mage]

Mathak, ive seen you do better. Ill give you 5/10 for your set. You should make it more noticeable ^_^

I tried to make my avvy and sig match but my computer screwed up so im stuck with a mismatched set for a while

[golden_djiin]

that siggy is pretty cool,and i like the milk thing,black mage.8/10

and your avvie is...not working.MWUHAHAHAHAHAH.

[Izar]

Black mage, the image jsut plain out rules, the quote's just odd. 11/10 for the image and 9/10 for the whole sig.

[Elliott]

Yeah, the signature image is pretty mad, I love the effects, and the colours you chose, quote is just wierd ^_^ . 8/10 for sig, 4 for set (no avatar)

[Black Mage]

But i have an avatar, hes right in the corner under my name, cant you see him ^_^

;) Thanks for the reveiws, best response iv gotten for a set

[Elliott]

All I get is a "no-hotlinking" message, uh, try not hotlinking?
There are plenty of free image hosts, as well as the fact you can upload your own avatar.

[Excalibur's Power]

Agatio-- Er, 8/10, the char. freaks me out for some reason...o.O

Black Mage--I"ll only rate the sig. ^^; 10/10, did you really make it?

[Black Mage]

Yeah, i made it a while back

I got a new avatar, can you guys see it?

Excally, ill give you 9/10, yours is cool

This post has been edited by Black Mage: 11 June 2005 - 09:08 AM

[Excalibur's Power]

Yes...

can you rate my sig?

[Black Mage]

i edited my last post, i gave you 9/10 for the set ^_^

[Elliott]

EP, the idea of this topic is to rate other's sets as well, if people continue to just ask for ratings, I will give warnings instead.

Nice new av BM,seen better, but it's better than a no hotlinking image, 6/10 for avatar, which gives you 7/10 for set.

[Izar]

What an offensive post...

1/10 for the sig. It's just a word, and the avatar is blurry and very low quality. Looks like it's from a Tony Hawk Game, I'm sure. 1/10

[Elliott]

Ollie: Avatar is the most distorted I have ever seen, and the original image isn't even that good. Sig is one word, no funny, looks bad. It isn't matching and it's ugly, 0.5/10 for set.

[Black Mage]

Agatio - 7.5/10

Izar - 7/10

Ollie - 0/10 Not only is the avatar bad, but you only have a single word in your sig. I'm pretty sure his avatar is from Tony Hawks pro Skater 4 but i cant say for sure since i havent played a tony hawk game in a while


EDIT: woah, i just realized izar is a mod, i always thought he was a member

[l3lueMage]

OMG BLACKMAGE STOLE MY NAME...DIE!!!!!!! @.@

but u also make AWSOME SIGS!!!
10/10 I WAS LIKE WOH OMG PRO!!!! Did you make/edit that font or download it?
avatar kinda kills it though...7/10 for that

overall 8/10 avatar really kills it!

[Mathak Kraven]

Since ollie didn't rate someone else's I won't rate his set, even though I would give a bad rating.

Blue Mage your av and sig are very nice. I give it an overall 8/10 knowing my ratings are good with such a high number.

[Wiflewood]

Nice Avatar Mathak, perhaps you could add the magicians protector balls in your sig to link with it. 6/10


New set for me!

[Mathak Kraven]

Maybe I will add the gaurdian balls and more... You got a nice set Wifle. 7.8/10

I'l look if I have any more space left, prolly not.

[Black Mage]

l3lueMage, on Jun 10 2005, 11:14 PM, said:

OMG BLACKMAGE STOLE MY NAME...DIE!!!!!!! @.@

I didnt steal your name, i borrowed it ;)

l3lueMage, ill give you 8/10 for yours

Mathak, yours is pretty good, i agree with the protector balls idea though, you should add them ^_^ 6/10 for yours

[Ollie The Magic Bum]

-You are warned again. You will be banned now, when Nick gets here. - Izar

[lifeform287]

Do something constuctive, dude.

l3luemage: Nice set. 10/10 definantly.
If your gonna rate me don't mind the lack of things. I'm workin on it.

[Toad King]

Avatar: 8/10

The animation isn't too bad, but isn't too good either.

And I know my avatar and signature don't match. I didn't make either of them. ^_^

[Izar]

He has been banned for his stupid posts. Thank you for reporting the posts.

Toad king - Avatar, dunno what it is, so, I'll just give it a 4/10, it's funny yeah, but low quality.

[Luna]

Izar's: D:... I don't really like it that much.
Avatar: 5/10
Sig: 7/10 x.x

[Izar]

Can I at least get a number rating on it? And when rating, please don't just give a rating, give a reason for each. Anyways, I'm fixin' to get another one.

Sheba - Avatar has kinda bad quality(see on the face? Bit blurry) and the signature, no offense, it's jsut kinda dumb. And the borders aren't complete. If it's not sopposed to have complete borders(like in a white background forum), that gives it a lower rating, because those are kinda tacky. Avatar - 6/10 and sig 6/10.

[Luna]

Er...how is that NOT a number rating? x_X;

Ok, I don't like the colours in your set and, the drawing looks crappy.

On my set: Both are supposed to be that way. The avatar was taken from a video in which the animation is modified so that it looks old. The sig has part of the lyrics for a song. And the borders are there to add a different and more artistic touch. I was hoping someone would appreaciate that.

[Mathak Kraven]

Black Mage, on Jun 11 2005, 05:14 PM, said:

Mathak, yours is pretty good, i agree with the protector balls idea though, you should add them :P 6/10 for yours

They won't line up very well, I already asked what is wrong so think as them being aligned perfectly

Sheba funny quote, I give it a 7.9/10

Avatar, I dunno really so I give it a 7.5/10 Just to be neatral.

[Nemphtis]

Hah, my latest shizzy... MAC10 biatch! Rate it the ghetto way.

[Neo]

yeh the 50 cent game, never played it... is it a good game?
well, the sig is quite good, not special, but good. 8/10
avy too... overall an 8

[Nemphtis]

I don't think it's out here yet, I doubt I'll buy it anyhow since it's probably just some cheap game anyhow. I'll check out some reviews just incase though, if it is good then I must go get it. =P

[Echo_djinn]

The pistol in your avatar is sick. 8.5/10 The G-Unit chains hanging off their necks are alright. Sparkle, sparkle. The guy holding the gun- the gun looks unique. Haven't seen that one. The misty fog look is great as well. 9/10 I need to make my own sig.

[Izar]

Sheba, on Jun 11 2005, 10:43 PM, said:

Er...how is that NOT a number rating? x_X;

Ok, I don't like the colours in your set and, the drawing looks crappy.

On my set: Both are supposed to be that way. The avatar was taken from a video in which the animation is modified so that it looks old. The sig has part of the lyrics for a song. And the borders are there to add a different and more artistic touch. I was hoping someone would appreaciate that.

Quote

Izar's: D:... I don't really like it that much.

How is it NOT a number rating? How IS it? There's NO NUMBERS in the rating you gave em, I'm not talking about the other ratings. And the drawing is sopposed to be a 5-minute drawing, it's not the whole pic.

If it's sopposed to be blurry, then that's an even worse avatar. 4/10 And taking away a part of the border is not any artistic touch to me. And don't say you were hoping someone would appreciate that. That's pretty rude. :P

Anubis - Good effect, but I hate Rap, so 7/10

[Luna]

Quote

Izar's: D:... I don't really like it that much.
Avatar: 5/10
Sig: 7/10 x.x

I meant that how are those two NOT number ratings e___e;

And ok.

I was hoping that PEOPLE would notice it was MEANT TO BE artistic. The italicized "someone" didn't have any second meaning/s to it.

[Izar]

I was talking about my rating.

Meant to be? I don't think anyone noticed, heh. Well, I think I've run outta people... Wait...

ED: Nice signature banner, I think I've rated you before, but it's a gone rating, so... 8.5/10, it's nice and the color is pretty cool.

[Elliott]

Too much text in the signature overall Izar, 1 or 2 lines is generally enough, as the diea of a signature is just something short at the end of every post.

Adding quotes from songs, MS info, and something trying to get people to read some book AS WELL AS an image is just a little over the top, and it comes across as looking messy.

5/10 for the siggy, the image just seems, like I said, messy, and the text ruins it moreso. Avatar is a bad cropping, as some text, but not all, can be seen. The only plus is that it matches.

Overall I would give a 6/10 for the set, and I suggest trimming the text, and trying another crop for the avatar.

[Nemphtis]

I've made several sigs on Photoshop but this one caught my eye out of the rest of the sets I made, I like the simplicity, the sleek feel yet the contrast of complexity given by the luuurvly gun. I'd apreciate it if you guys rated it and pointed out anything you think I should take off or add.

http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/yuukaidragon/deagleav.gif

http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/yuukaidragon/deaglesig.jpg

[Elliott]

Love the text, and it owns your current set, so use it <_< .

[Nemphtis]

The main reason I made it how it is now is to make it blend perfectly with my forums skin. I personally love it and I usually can't apreciate anything I make myself but this one just looks cool, period. =]

[Echo_djinn]

Instead of saying in the sig you showed us" Yo' ass is ruled." I think it would be better to say "Yo' ass is owned." Just my opinion. Everything else is alright.

[Nemphtis]

So you think "Pulled" rhymes with "0wned", eh? Interesting... O_o

[Echo_djinn]

It doesn't need to rhyme to sound good my friend. Seems like you got rid of that phrase and put in a new one. It's all good. Sounds better then the other one as well.

[Izar]

Agatio, on Jun 14 2005, 01:04 AM, said:

Too much text in the signature overall Izar, 1 or 2 lines is generally enough, as the diea of a signature is just something short at the end of every post.

Adding quotes from songs, MS info, and something trying to get people to read some book AS WELL AS an image is just a little over the top, and it comes across as looking messy.

5/10 for the siggy, the image just seems, like I said, messy, and the text ruins it moreso. Avatar is a bad cropping, as some text, but not all, can be seen. The only plus is that it matches.

Overall I would give a 6/10 for the set, and I suggest trimming the text, and trying another crop for the avatar.

You rated me already, I think twice. :P Least ya gave me a better rating this time.

And It's not too long, I maxed the character limit, why else are the extra one's there? <_< :)

[Wiflewood]

I Like it Izar, it has a nice graffiti look to it. Dimensions are perhaps a bit off for the sig, but overall a fantastic set. 9/10

[Izar]

Yeah, 401 x 131, I added borders and it got too big, forgot that it didn't overlap.

WifleWood: Nice there, but who is the dude? 8.5/10, the guy is just a bit blurry.

[Elliott]

Good set Wiflewood.

The blending of the character, and the character itself is very cool. Text could be improved, maybe a more legible font? Or another colour? Matching is always a plus. But maybe make the main image a link to your site to avoid having a cluttered signature?

8/10 overall. Very nice.

[l3lueMage]

Wifle yours is very interesting yet very stunning 10/10 for overall nice D:

rate mine, sig took me forever =(

btw i finally understand what naruto is about after watchin the movie. the comics were kinda confusing :silence:

[Nemphtis]

8/10 it looks cool but I don't think the background render or whatever it is doesn't mix well with the rest of the sig.

Can you guys rate my current set and this sig:

http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/yuukaidragon/rippedsig.gif

[Elliott]

Anubis: Transparancy for a signature is good when used in moderation, but I think it's a little overused in that image.
You set is good. Basic, but aesthetically please :silence: . 8/10

Wifle. Good set. The background render doesn't blend well with the character, but the overall look of the set is great, well done. 8/10 for set.

[Nemphtis]

Oh yeah and rate this one please, I've been experimenting with effects etc. for an hour which is why I got these extra sigs.

http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/yuukaidragon/pinkynesssig.gif

[Elliott]

Very sexy, but not your style. Typography ain't that great, but overall it's a bood looking image. Add a border.

[Nemphtis]

There is a border, problem is, it's white.

I tried a black border and it just stood out waaaay too much from the rest of the sig, so I made it white but now you can't see it if teh BG is bright. :silence:

[Elliott]

If you only try black and white borders you need a less on in colour :silence: .
Try #333 or #555, those are usually safe bets, or try a darker version of the pink.

[Echo_djinn]

When was hot chicks wearing tight clothes ever your style Anubis? Don't answer that. :silence:

Like agatio said a border would make it stand out better, though I am sure it stands out pretty nicely already. The words in the text are a bit hard to read since it blends right in with the backround. Maybe you could make the text darker so it's more readable.

[Izar]

Stick to the one you got now anubis, the others ones look bad kinda, the second one mostly.

[Wiflewood]

I rated the banner before Izar, but the quotes are cool. Nice set. 8/10
Agatio: I prefered it when you had the image, but the quote is very philosophical (and true), and the Avatar is amazing. 10/10.

My new set: More graphical and colourful, but it is just a temporary set till I finish my new one. But do you like it better than the old one?
Or, do you like THIS set better:
http://img191.echo.cx/img191/7288/avvie1iv.gif(also nonanimated version)
http://img191.echo.cx/img191/9751/grahamsig5wi.png

[Izar]

Nice Wifle. I like the swirling. ^_^ That art's not my kinda art, but it looks cool. 8/10

[pHantOm]

I keep it simple...lol

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v459/EPPhantom/Sigs/Siggycopy3.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v459/EPPhantom/Sigs/Avatarcopy.jpg

meh...Im kinda noob but thats ok. Im proud that I model my own abstract art and not rip the render. I just like simple stuff for forums like my current one.

[My Best Wishes]

pHantOm-I don't like the one you posted. The stars and the colours of the city? don't work well, i reckon either have one or the other, maybe a darker shade of green, or something a little murky. Don't take my opinion to much, i suck at that type of stuff. 8/10

Agatio-The eye's old. The quote is very you. 7/10

Anubis-I like the first one. With the background how it seems to be swirling or something, and the colours behind the guy and the colours of the guy himself. Plus how you leave gaps between the stuff. 9/10

Wiflewood-It's dark and mysterious. Different. 8.5/10

^_^ Shock, i've changed my avatar and sig, it's only been about two months.

[theblueflames]

Watch, yours is pretty cool, but....hard to tell if its an official image or not. ;) Mine isn't actually mine, I found it on FooFighters website, shrunk it and put on an antique yellow effect with the words. I still like it though ^_^.

Up there, Echo-Djinn's is very cool, but the avatar doesn't really match...anyways I'd say 6.5/10 for the sig.

[pHantOm]

watch, on Jun 29 2005, 07:21 PM, said:

pHantOm-I don't like the one you posted. The stars and the colours of the city? don't work well, i reckon either have one or the other, maybe a darker shade of green, or something a little murky. Don't take my opinion to much, i suck at that type of stuff. 8/10

Agatio-The eye's old. The quote is very you. 7/10

Anubis-I like the first one. With the background how it seems to be swirling or something, and the colours behind the guy and the colours of the guy himself. Plus how you leave gaps between the stuff. 9/10

Wiflewood-It's dark and mysterious. Different. 8.5/10

^_^ Shock, i've changed my avatar and sig, it's only been about two months.

Yeah, I think its kinda ugly myself. But its the only matching set I have ;) I like plain ones that are pretty things for the eyes. Even though they dont take amazing skill, if they look nice and never get old thats what matters to me.

[theblueflames]

Phantom, your sig is very clean...and white! But sorta unoriginal. I vaguely remember seeing something similar somewhere....ahwell 6/10. ^_^

[pHantOm]

theblueflames, on Jun 29 2005, 11:43 PM, said:

Phantom, your sig is very clean...and white! But sorta unoriginal. I vaguely remember seeing something similar somewhere....ahwell 6/10. ^_^

I know, but its clean ;) secondly Im the only Phantom ive ever seen in =EP=...so that proves I didnt rip. :D

I need to get an Inuyasha sig, Kagome is hot ^_^

[Luna]

pHantOm:
Avatar: 7.5/10 >.o; It's sort of...over-used.
Signature: 8.5/10 Banner is pretty and the other two are amusing <<;
Set: I don't rate "sets" :D

My "set" is PINK. That's a first.

[Neo]

Sheba -- another Naruto lover eh ^_^... 10 for avatar, and 8 for sig.

[Nemphtis]

NG - I like the blend of colours used, everything goes well nicely with eachother. Sadly it's hard to tell what exactly the image is, a caped man perhaps? I can't be sure, but a good set none-the-less. 9/10

[theblueflames]

Sheba's is hilarious, thats gotta be like Shirley Temple or something... 7.5/10, funney. NG its cool 8/10.

[Wiflewood]

Nice matching set flames, however the dimensions of the sig are a little off. No matter, nice and matching, and because its greyscale, it makes it feels more solem. 8/10

[Neo]

wifle -- freaky! that heas is serious freaky. nice bg with it, text is good, but can be better (try Psycho Poetry as font). 8.5/10 for set

[theblueflames]

I think the font 'Chiller' would work best, but then, I've never seen Psycho Peotry either...

[Nemphtis]

TBF, guy in the avatar looks like Bruce Lee in American form. The people behind look... slightly deformed. I find it amusing, this I award it an 8/10 for making me laugh.

[theblueflames]

Its Dave Grohl xD . The guys in back were already kinda blurry when I put on the atique effect, so it made 'em worse. Thanks for the 8 though ;). Your avatar is...funney :P 7/10.

[Elliott]

The low quality of yor set kills it theblueflames. If both images were better quallity, and maybe had more colour, they would get a good rating. At least they match though, that's something. 5/10 for set.

Anubis, I know you can do better. Non existant signature, and pretty low quallity avatar, 3/10 for set.

Sheba: Your avatar is very close to the best I have ever seen you use, it's awesome. Maybe a matching signature would be good? 7/10 for set (that avatar is just plain cool).

[Neo]

Agatio -- the avatar is good, but the signature is way too simple. 6/10 for the set

New set. the sig and avy don't match, but they're the same person.

[theblueflames]

Agatio, on Jun 30 2005, 08:21 PM, said:

The low quality of yor set kills it theblueflames. If both images were better quallity, and maybe had more colour, they would get a good rating. At least they match though, that's something. 5/10 for set.

The distortion was intentional bro...and I cropped the dude's head from my sig, its supposed to look that way.

[Elliott]

Don't you just hate it when people get defensive over a set rating they don't like? I was being constructive, and offered ways in which it could improve, would you rather that or I say it's just crap straight out? I know which I would prefer.

[Nemphtis]

Actually I'd prefer it if you said it was crap, straight out. Skip the bullshiz and just say what you think. It leads to the same conclusion, the only difference is one way takes longer to explain and the other one is blunt and to the point.

[theblueflames]

Agatio, on Jul 3 2005, 03:50 AM, said:

Don't you just hate it when people get defensive over a set rating they don't like? I was being constructive, and offered ways in which it could improve, would you rather that or I say it's just crap straight out? I know which I would prefer.

I wasn't being defensive, I know you were being constructive, and so was I, I pointed out that some of the stuff you said I did on purpose, therefore it didn't need to improve in that factor.

[Neo]

Anubis; Good Background, and nice image of 50. main text is good, but the quote is too long. 8/10

[Elliott]

Your sets are always great Neo Genesis. Despite not matching, your current is still very good.

4/5 for the signature, good blending, good character, but the typography isn't too crash hot, and the 'd' is a little hard to make out.

Avatar is very nice. Good composition, looks cool, nice colours, but it seems a tad blurry, and comes across as slightly low quality. For that it gets a 4/5.

Total set rating: 8/10

[Nemphtis]

Awesome smiley, looks funny when it was blown up. Avatar is not bad either. :agitated: 7/10

[Elliott]

Great set Anubis. Matching, nice colours, text easy to read ('cept on the avatar), good blending and nice effect. Good job, 9/10.

[Neo]

Indeed, nice new set Anubis. maybe the opicity of the pattern could be a little lower, but furthermore a great set 9/10

Agatio -- Bleach, never really watched it... but heard alot about it and also saw small parts. nice avatar with color. 8/10
the siggy is funny, but nothing great. 5/10

[Izar]

Anbubis: Nice, 8/10, it just looks a litte scratchy, the images of the dude I mean.

Agatio: Kinda boring. The avatar is ok, 7.5/10, but the sig is annoying.

Anyways, mines kinda oring, a little too soft. It wasn't sopposed to be this soft, but it's ok. It's not my best, but I tried.

[loz]

I have rated you Izar...
Neo nice set I like the background...8/10

Please rate both sigs <.<

http://img26.imageshack.us/img26/2666/sig3sm.jpg

[Neo]

first one:
the bg is good, though a little too bright. the image of gaara however, is very strange. I know he is supposed to look like that in that image, but it still looks a bit streched. the text is ok. 7/10

second:
background and text are great. but the image doesnt really fit in it. try blending it in trough color or fading. and the yoshi ruins it a bit... 7/10

[loz]

lol, the yoshi is a seperate image is for the yoshi club at the ToS forums, I just never took it out of my sig code thingy XD

[Wiflewood]

Nice avvie loz, I like the way it's orange hue ties in with the sig, which is very good also.
There are some bits of the Sig's image that aren't quite right (blue background behind some of the center guy's hair, black background behind the girl's hair) But overall, very good.
8/10

[Nemphtis]

Wiflewood, the guy in your set looks like he has sniffed more coke than humanly possible! :agitated: 7/10

[lifeform287]

Anubis, on Jul 8 2005, 12:43 PM, said:

Wiflewood, the guy in your set looks like he has sniffed more coke than humanly possible! :lol: 7/10

Sad but true. Thats why it rules.

Anubis: Yours is pretty good. I have NO CLUE where that is from so...thats better for me I guess. 9/10

[Mysterious Adept]

Nice theres no more words that can describe that

10/10!!!

[el_Sethro]

I made a new set based on the Doomsday Spectre, my favorite Magic: The Gathering card. this sig is the first one I've made that actually had some effort required to create it. I actually went on photoshop, cropped the image, used a filter, and added my name in a font that I downloaded from the internet. I even added a border. This may not sound like much, but I'm very proud of my newly-acquired photohopping skills, thank you very much!

Anubis: very cool. sorry I can't make a more technical analysis than that, but I like it a lot.

Mysterious Adept: the sig's fine, looks great, avatar lacks effort (although i can't say much now, can I?). Not very original, but still pretty good.

[Wiflewood]

I don't like the way that your sig is 'watercoloured' but the avvie isn't Sethro, I think it would look better if they were the same. Other than that, very nice :o 8/10

Azathoth: Avatar is too cliched methinks, I have seen it on many different forums for different users. Maybe one in the style of your sig, which is pretty good, but with boring text. 7/10

[Nemphtis]

New set. I know it looks plain but I was experimenting with the latest big thing in graphics. Pixel stretch effects. I just wanted to make a quick set since I was getting bored of my old Coded Arms one.

Wifle I've rated yours before so Azaroth; I dislike your avatar as it just doesn't fit my liking and your sig looks too plainy in the sense that it feels like something made on Paint. 5/10

EDIT: Actually, this is one of my old sets but if anybody wants to rate, go ahead.

http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/yuukaidragon/ballaav.gif

http://jupiter.walagata.com/w/yuukaidragon/ballasig.gif

[el_Sethro]

Azathoth: hmmm... I guess I'll have to learn to do things with text, then? I guess I'm off to play with photoshop some more...
(by the way, it's not a sea monster; it's a kind of dragon the spectre is riding)

Wiflewood: very cool. it really creates the kinda spooky atmosphere...

Anubis (current): simple theme, but the consistancy in colour really looks good.
Anubis (other): it's good, but the basketballs don't seem very appropriate to me... maybe I just don't get it.

[Nemphtis]

I'm a balla, I think the basketballs were a nice symbol of that.

[Elliott]

Been a while since I posted here. el sethro, the dimensions of your avatar are new, maybe a 1 pixel black border would make it looks better, I like how the sig matches as well. I don't like the effects on the sig though, the avatar looks very clear, but the signature blurry and harder to make out. Overall, an 8/10 for your set.

[Izar]

Agatio - Just Thrall, and no text, but it's thrall, and he's a good hero. 6/10

Anubis - Kinda, boring. And he kinda looks cross-eyed there. :o 5/10 And the baskettball one, Kinda wierd. The saying is jsut one of those made to sound cool I guess, But I love baskettball, so that's a 7/10

el sethro - Text isn't that great, and I don't like magic cards, but how you dealed with the image is actually pretty neat. 6.5/10

[Excalibur's Power]

Agatio...uh, 6.5/10.

Anubis - I just don't like the text. 7/10, or basketball one, 8/10.

Izar - I like lightning...it's so...shiny...9/10

[Wiflewood]

EP: I don't really like the borders on the avatar, and I don't know why there is a random sprite in the bottom left of your sig, but the rest of it is fantastic, I really like the way the image blends with the background. 8/10

[Izar]

I got a new one. It's some girl on the cd of TFK's "The Art of Breaking." I was debating whether or not I should use that or one from Family Guy.

Ep: Well, it's a good background there whoever he is, but I reckon you need a different border. The text is kinda hard to read, but I think it's good. Oh, that was your avatar rating. For some reason, I can't see your sig. 8/10

[Nick Presta]

http://www.goldensun-syndicate.net/forum/i...t=0#entry201279

Which looks better?

[Izar]

That was an odd closing. :D Well, I think the first one is better, more images on the side, 8/10. The other is good, just, I dunno 7/10.

[Mars Djinni]

nick1presta, on Jul 24 2005, 02:48 PM, said:

http://www.goldensun-syndicate.net/forum/i...t=0#entry201279

Which looks better?

Second one would've been better with a different font, but I think I'll agree with Izar. First one's better.

[Elliott]

He must have deleted my post in which I said this is a better and more conveniet topic to post something like this. I like the first one better, though a better font wouldn't go astray.

Izar: A 1 pixel black border would do the set good, other than that it's nice. Maybe a better font though?

[Izar]

Well it's nick's post. I saw that you closed it, but I was confused.

Well, I would but the black border, but I use this image in forums with black backgrounds. I test my sigs there alot. I tried modeling the font to the band's font, but I just said forget it, reckon I'd jsut use something simple.

MD - Nice. Everyone and Mapls Story. :D 8/10 But the guy should be centered in the sig image.

[gsninja]

Izar-The avie and siggy look very nice, seeing as it's very clear and all.

Avie & siggy-9/10
Set-10/10

[Izar]

Is it because it's a girl? (a pretty one at that) lol.

I don't like Full Metal Alchemist, but the text and image are clear, so that's good. 8/10 in all.

[gsninja]

No, not really, but I guess it could be part of the reason...

MD-For some reason, I'm already starting to get a little tired of Maple Story...but the avie and siggy still look good nonetheless.

Avie/siggy-7.8/10
Set-10/10

[Wiflewood]

It's a bit boring GSN, Its just a basic image, no editing, with a bit of text. Not very much work gone in to it, but its not horrendous. 5/10

[Neo]

Wifle; something new, and looks good. Very simple, but effective. Set matches. The only comment I can give is the font. I advice using another.

[Izar]

I like the new one Wiflewood. Nice effects, it rocks. 9/10 because it's just a little simple.

[el_Sethro]

Introducing... el Sethro's Frances the Mute set!!!

it's basically a medley of artwork from the album, and I put in some lyrics in there in the exact same font and colour as they appear in the album sleeve (which is why I dodn't try to use any filters/effects on the text). The avatar is just a part of the album cover that I cropped. Anyway, I'm pretty proud of it (it required effort to make).


Agatio: I've seen that picture (your avatar) before. it's pretty awesome.

Izar: I think I'd have cropped the image differently, personally, and the text is kinda boring. and there's a little strip going across the bottom that's a little teensy bit more vivid than the rest.
Those are just little things, though. other than that, it's not bad.

Wiflewood: weird/awesome. I like it.

[Echo_djinn]

Wilfe: You seem to have a disturbing fascination to go for disfigured avatars. Have you killed a few people in your life time? 7.5/10 Just plain black and white. Looks like a quick sketch.

[Wiflewood]

Not that I know of ED. :)

Izar: Pretty good quality image, font is a bit boring though. 7/10

El Sethro: Avatar is a bit weird, but good quality. I like the way that you don't use square avatars. The signature is a bit crowded, and maybe you could have used different shades of red, but the images look cool and give it a suitably narcotic feel. 7/10

ED: Signature is very good, nice clear font. The Avatar is a cool pose, a bit blurry, but good none the less. 8/10

[Jai]

Wiflewood: I'm guessing that your avatar and sig is custom but I find it very confusing so sice I was raise by the concept of: "If you cant say anything good then dont say anything at all" so umm i guess gonna give you a 8/10 for effort.

[Izar]

Jai - Nice actually... Well, the signature. FF7 jsut palin oout rules all. 7/10 for it being too big, and a bit boring.

[Mars Djinni]

Izar:

Did I rate you before? ah well, I like the greenish theme in it. Font's not that great though. Avatar does fit well, but it seems to be cut from the sig.

Avatar: 7.5/10
Sig: 8.5/10
Set: 9/10

Jai:

Gotta love that FF7. Avatar is unedited, as Izar said, it's a bit boring. The Avatar and sig together fit in quite nicely though.

Avatar: 6.5/10
Sig: 8/10
Set: 8/10

[Unicornmaddy]

Mars your avatar is very cool it's one of the monsters from Maple Story and that carries through to the sig, however a bit boring I'd give it... 7/10

[Mars Djinni]

Uni:

The Image to the right in your sig is cool, but the other one's a bit too plain. The theming of horses and unicorns are consistant, so it doesn't get too boring. Avatar's a bit too dark for my liking, though.

Avatar: 6.5/10
Sig: 7/10
Set: 9/10

[Izar]

Mars Djinni, on Aug 19 2005, 02:32 PM, said:

Izar:

Did I rate you before? ah well, I like the greenish theme in it. Font's not that great though. Avatar does fit well, but it seems to be cut from the sig.

Avatar: 7.5/10
Sig: 8.5/10
Set: 9/10

Yours is like... cut from your sig too... And I think you might have rated mine already.

I like yours, but the older one was a bit better. It was more... Colorful...8/10 in all.

EDIT: Added my Trigun set.

[Mycarayne]

MD: A very simple set. Having said that, for a simple set, it is very effective.

9/10

[Zxor]

MR your sig...I don't really have any words to explain it....mr woz ere? But, it really is simple and simple is good. 8/10 good font.

[Neo]

another maple sig... the first few were original, now its just dull; 5/10

[Fallen Sephiroth]

umm.... lyrics are ok not the est thing in the world though

4/10

[Crimson Barrel Knight]

Fallen Sephiroth

Avatar - Pretty good cut-out, but needs a border. 6/10
Signature - Awesome. Simply awesome. But it's too big for the maximum size limit for signatures. 8/10

[Izar]

As long a signature doesn't actually change the borders of the board size, then for now, I think it would be alright.

FS - Center your signature, other than that, I give it a 9/10. It's pretty good.

[Crimson Barrel Knight]

Bwar. Didn't even rate mine. =/

Izar
Avatar - Cut out from the signature, I believe. 6/10
Signature - Could use a little tweaking. Other than that, it's mild. 6.5/10

[Izar]

Which set you talking about? The trigun or Maple story? And so what if it's cut out from the sig?

For some reaon my sig image ain't bordered. I bordered and uploaded the pic, but for some odd reason... It aint showin.

[Elliott]

FS: Nice signature man, but the avatar just doesn't match up. 7/10 for set.

CBK: Interesting colours, but overall the set is a little messy. 6/10

Izar: Pretty bland. Maybe some contrast in the font. That, and the MS set has been done to death on this forum, so it's nothing new. 6.8/10. And don't bother rating mine Izar, I already know what the gist of it will be.

[Nemphtis]

CBK - I like your new set. Red is cool, robots rawk, for once you've done something decent. 8/10

Izar - There's making something look simple, and then there's making something look cheap. If it wasn't for the hobo who has a pot on his head that sig would be VERY crappy but you get extra points for the hobo. 5/10

[Crimson Barrel Knight]

You don't really have to rate 'em. Just show 'em off. It's kinda like an advertising thing for when people want to come crawling to you and ask for a custom-made one. =P

Here's a couple/few of mine.

http://img381.imageshack.us/img381/4900/boygirllove7gm.gif
http://img382.imageshack.us/img382/852/angercontrolsig3yu.gif
http://img394.imageshack.us/img394/3226/cantidosamasig3kk.gif

[Nemphtis]

Erm, why not just put these in the set rating topic? If the concept is to post p your sigs then you're better off posting in the set rating topic.

[Crimson Barrel Knight]

'Cause you don't have to rate them. I believe the Set Rating topic is for just the set you currently have.

[Nemphtis]

Well what you believe is wrong. The set rating topic is to post up your sets, not just your current ones so you can get some opinions/advice/ratings for them.

[Fallen Sephiroth]

Izar, on Aug 28 2005, 06:06 PM, said:

As long a signature doesn't actually change the borders of the board size, then for now, I think it would be alright.

FS - Center your signature, other than that, I give it a 9/10. It's pretty good.

if i knew how i would

[Elliott]

[ c e n t e r ]
Your signature
[ / c e n t e r ]

That, but without the spaces between the letters.

Anubis: Cartoon porn is very ghey, but your set looks overall pretty good. Nice colours, good border, simple, and it matches. Nice work. 9/10.

[Nemphtis]

Well where I come from, underwear is something everyone wears through their daily lives and is not considered pornographic or even personal. Anyone who lives in London will agree that they see people openly showing off their underwear. ;P

Also Sephiroth don't centre your signature, it will make yours look bad. Your signature is better suited in the position it's in, my only quarrell is that you don't have a matching avatar.

[Neo]

Nice one Anubis. great bg, and I love the quote. render is funny too. 9/10

[Elliott]

New avatar.

Neo Genesis: The lyrics in your signature gave me a laugh. How can you expect to be taken seriously with something so lame in your signature? 6/10 for set, cause the avatar is nice.

[Wiflewood]

Agatio
Reminds me of some kind of 80's action figure box art. Pretty cool, the guy looks very impressive. 8/10

Lyrics are also cool. Nothing too 'WOW' though. 7/10

[Elliott]

Yeah, I had a bit of trouble finding some lyrics that I thought were awesome. These will have to do for now. The guy in my avatar is the 'mascot' for the band Manowar (kind of hard rock).

Your set is great Wiflewood, but I think you need to lose the buttons, and the text (ROFL). 7/10 overall.

[Nemphtis]

Well according to Eugine who sent me a PM, he actually thinks my current set is I quote; "Not PG". I had no idea some of you people think that underwear is related to sex, you're all wearing some right now, so why even bltch about it?

[Someone Else]

Well, it's just that... you know, between the legs... > o;


But, yeah the quote is funny and over all a very... nice looking set. XD

8/10

What think of mine?

[Ravenblade]

If one of the female members put up a sig with a guy in tight underwear, would you want to be looking at it? Does it matter so much anyways...take it down if Eugine said to. Its not the underwear, its the fact it clings to her curves and is revealing. If you put the underwear up on its own without her, no one would have a problem @_@

and i cant see WD's because China blocks out anything with ".us" on the end of it - thus all imageshack images are down for me ._.

[Izar]

Anubis, it's not really about that, It's too showy for younger members. And don't announce a Moderator's decision publically.

Before I rate WD's signature... What acatly is that graphic?